Got a Student Loan Refund? Prepare to Pay it Back for 2025

Student Finance & Loan Expert

Many students find themselves with a student loan refund, an unexpected windfall that might seem like a gift. However, this refund is essentially part of your loan balance, and you need to understand its implications to manage your finances effectively. Having spoken with loan experts and several student borrowers, I prepared this guide to help you navigate the intricacies of student loan refunds and how they impact your repayment strategy.

In June 2023, the Supreme Court struck down President Biden's plan to forgive up to $20,000 in student loans per borrower. As a result, interest started accruing again on September 1, 2023, and payments resumed on October 1, 2023. Over 16 million borrowers who were conditionally approved for forgiveness now face the task of repaying their loans.

Key Things You Should Know About Student Loan Refunds

Four years post-graduation, 48% of Black and 17% of White borrowers owe more than they borrowed, with overborrowing affecting 40% of Black and 22% of White graduate students.
The 2022 White House announcement of up to $10,000 in debt cancellation made refunds attractive, prompting borrowers to request them to lower balances below cancellation thresholds.
Low-income (39%) and high-income (40%) students borrow similarly, but 32% and 21% exceed tuition costs, respectively.
Keeping the refund offers immediate relief and an emergency fund but increases your loan balance, leading to higher debt and longer repayment periods.
To return your refund, contact your loan servicer, complete required forms, and return it promptly to apply it to your principal balance.

What is a Student Loan Refund?
Who Received Student Loan Refunds?
Are There Alternatives to Using Student Loan Refunds?
The Impact of Refund on Your Loan Balance
Should You Keep or Return Your Refund?
Does Keeping a Student Loan Refund Impact My Credit Score?
Is Investing Your Student Loan Refund in Competency Based Universities a Smart Move?
Does My Student Loan Refund Affect Future Financial Aid or Scholarship Opportunities?
How Do Education Loan Lenders Evaluate Student Loan Refund Decisions?
How Do You Choose the Right Student Loan Lender?
Should I Consult a Financial Advisor Before Deciding on My Student Loan Refund?
Will Returning My Student Loan Refund Improve My Income-Driven Repayment Options?
Does a Student Loan Refund Affect Loan Forgiveness Eligibility?
How to Return Your Refund
Managing Your Finances with a Student Loan Refund
Can Your Student Loan Refund Be Invested in Future Academic Opportunities?
How Can Student Loan Refunds Help Fund Nursing School?
Other Things You Should Know about Student Loan Refunds

What is a Student Loan Refund?

A student loan refund occurs when your loan disbursement exceeds your educational costs, such as tuition, fees, and campus housing. The excess amount is then refunded to you, typically at the beginning of each semester.

Why Do Refunds Happen?

Refunds can occur for several reasons:

Over-borrowing: You borrowed more than you needed for educational expenses.
Scholarships and grants: You received additional aid after your loan was disbursed.
Dropping courses: You dropped classes or reduced your credit load, lowering your cost of attendance.

Student loans are meant to equalize college graduates by race. But there are nuances suggesting the U.S. higher education won't see this goal through any time soon. Four years post-graduation, 48% of Black student borrowers and 17% of White student borrowers owe more than their original loan, with overborrowing contributing to additional debt for 40% of Black graduate students and 22% of White graduate students.

Who Received Student Loan Refunds?

In unique situations as in the Biden plan, an anticipated loan forgiveness program from the White House set off students to request a refund. In this case, refunds were not automatically issued; only borrowers who specifically requested them received refunds.

Pandemic Pause Payments

During the pandemic pause, payments made on federal student loans were eligible for refunds. However, with loan cancellation off the table and payments restarting, these refunded amounts are being added back to borrowers' loan balances.

Influence of the Loan Forgiveness Announcement

The White House's 2022 announcement of canceling up to $10,000 in federal student debt per borrower, or $20,000 for Pell Grant recipients, made refunds particularly attractive. Borrowers who made payments during the zero-interest pause to reduce their balances below these cancellation thresholds sought refunds preemptively.

For instance, a borrower with $15,000 in student debt as of July 2020 made a $7,500 lump sum payment during the pause, reducing their debt to $7,500. Upon hearing about the cancellation plan, they requested a $5,000 refund, raising their balance to $12,500, which was just below the $15,000 cancellation limit.

Federal student loan servicers then mailed out the requested refund checks to eligible borrowers.

Impact of the Supreme Court Decision

Following the Supreme Court's decision to strike down President Biden's student debt cancellation plan in June 2023, borrowers remain liable for their full loan balances, including any refunded amounts.

Ineligible Loans

Private student loan payments, as well as some FFEL Program or Perkins loans, were not included in the forbearance and thus were ineligible for payment refunds.

no. of students who borrowed more than they paid for in tuition & fees

Are There Alternatives to Using Student Loan Refunds?

While student loan refunds offer immediate financial relief, they come with long-term financial consequences such as increased interest and higher monthly payments. Exploring alternatives to using these refunds can be a financially savvy move for students aiming to minimize debt.

Scholarships and Grants. Instead of relying on a refund, students can actively search for scholarships and grants, which do not need to be repaid. Many institutions, private organizations, and nonprofits provide funds specifically for tuition, fees, or living expenses. These awards can ease the financial burden without the added cost of accruing interest.
Part-Time Employment. Taking on a part-time job can be another effective way to cover living expenses while in school. Many colleges have work-study programs that allow students to work on campus, often in flexible roles designed to accommodate academic schedules.
Emergency Savings. If you anticipate needing funds for unexpected costs, consider building an emergency savings fund before taking out loans. This approach will not only reduce reliance on refunds but also prepare you for financial emergencies without increasing your debt burden.
Targeted Loans for Specific Needs. In some cases, opting for a more targeted loan might serve your purposes better. For instance, private loans tailored to specific student needs, like the ones discussed in college ave student loans pros and cons, can sometimes offer more favorable terms for covering essential expenses without unnecessary borrowing.

By carefully considering these alternatives, students can avoid the long-term costs associated with retaining loan refunds while still meeting their financial needs effectively and responsibly.

What is the Impact of Refund on Your Loan Balance?

The U.S. has a high cost of college by country; hence, students turn to student loans. But borrowing beyond your educational needs will impact your loan balance and, ultimately, your long-term debt, a scenario low-income students often find themselves in. In one study, students from the lowest income quintile (39%) and the highest income quintile (40%) are found to almost equally likely to take out student loans, but 32% of low-income students borrow more than their tuition costs compared to 21% of high-income students.

Here's how loan refunds, or excess loan, can impact your loan balance:

Interest Accumulation

Interest on your student loan begins accruing as soon as the loan is disbursed. If you decide to keep the refund, this amount is added to your principal balance, and you will end up paying interest on it. Over time, this additional interest can significantly increase the overall cost of your loan. For example, if you received a $5,000 refund and it accrues interest at a rate of 5% annually, you could end up paying an extra $2,500 in interest over the life of the loan.

Increased Monthly Payments

Keeping the refund results in a higher loan balance, which translates to larger monthly payments once you start repaying your loan. A larger balance means you'll face higher monthly payments, which can put a strain on your budget and financial planning after graduation. Let’s say you initially owed $20,000 and received a $5,000 refund, your new balance of $25,000 will lead to higher monthly payments compared to if you had not taken the refund. This could significantly impact your ability to manage other expenses and save for future goals.

Example Scenario

Consider a student who borrowed $18,000 and received a $4,000 refund during the loan pause. After the refund, their total loan balance increased to $22,000. If the interest rate is 6%, this extra $4,000 will accrue interest, making the total repayment amount much higher over the life of the loan. When they begin repayment, their monthly payments will be based on this larger balance, potentially increasing their monthly payment by around $40 to $50, depending on the loan term. This adjustment can strain their finances, especially as they transition from student life to the workforce.

Should You Keep or Return Your Refund?

Deciding whether to keep or return your student loan refund requires careful consideration of how it will impact your long-term financial health.

Keeping the Refund

Pros:

Immediate financial relief: The refund can cover living expenses, books, and other personal costs.
Emergency fund: It can act as a safety net for unexpected expenses during the semester.

Cons:

Higher debt: Keeping the refund increases your overall loan balance and the amount of interest you’ll pay.
Long-term financial burden: The higher balance can lead to longer repayment periods and more financial stress.

Returning the Refund

Pros:

Lower debt: Returning the refund reduces your overall loan balance and the amount of interest you’ll pay.
Easier repayment: A smaller loan balance means more manageable monthly payments after graduation.

Cons:

Immediate financial strain: Returning the refund may leave you with less money for living expenses and emergencies during the semester.

Whether you should keep or return your student loan refund depends on how it will impact your long-term financial health. In general, returning the refund is often the more prudent choice, as it reduces your overall loan balance and minimizes the total interest paid. After all, the refund is not your money but funds provided by taxpayers, making it even more important to handle it responsibly.

federal student loan amount cancelled by Biden

Does Keeping a Student Loan Refund Impact My Credit Score?

Keeping a student loan refund increases your outstanding balance, which may indirectly influence your credit profile. Lenders assess factors such as debt-to-income ratios and overall indebtedness when evaluating creditworthiness; a higher balance could affect future refinancing options and access to competitive interest rates. Maintaining a track record of on-time payments and actively monitoring your credit report is essential to mitigate any potential negative impact. For individuals exploring alternative career paths with manageable educational investments, consider the opportunities in good paying medical jobs with little schooling as part of a broader financial strategy.

Is Investing Your Student Loan Refund in Competency Based Universities a Smart Move?

Competency-based programs offer accelerated learning and cost-efficient pathways that some borrowers find appealing when reassessing their educational investments. Allocating refund funds toward these alternative institutions can create opportunities for career advancement and financial efficiency by reducing overall time-to-degree and related costs. Evaluating the curriculum structure, accreditation status, and alignment with specific career goals is crucial before committing to this approach. Borrowers should weigh the potential long-term return on investment against the immediate benefit of reducing their loan balance. This focus on demonstrated skills and knowledge, rather than seat time, is precisely the model embraced by competency-based universities. These institutions are specifically designed around the principle of allowing students to progress at their own pace, often by demonstrating mastery of specific competencies through assessments, making them particularly attractive for individuals seeking to leverage prior learning or accelerate their degree completion.

Does My Student Loan Refund Affect Future Financial Aid or Scholarship Opportunities?

A student loan refund, when retained and added to your outstanding balance, may indirectly influence how financial aid offices assess your overall financial profile. While refund amounts are not counted as income on applications, a higher debt load could affect the calculation of need-based aid and eligibility for certain scholarships. Institutional financial aid policies vary, so it is crucial to verify with your school’s financial aid office whether your increased balance might lead to adjustments in future aid packages. For specialized paths, including programs at military friendly colleges, consulting with a financial aid advisor can provide tailored guidance on maintaining an optimal profile for upcoming scholarship and grant evaluations.

How Do Education Loan Lenders Evaluate Student Loan Refund Decisions?

Retaining a student loan refund increases your outstanding balance, which may affect the overall debt profile considered by lenders. This additional balance can influence credit risk assessments and may impact the terms of future borrowing. Lenders analyze complex factors such as your repayment history, debt-to-income ratio, and portfolio composition when determining eligibility and interest rates. Enhanced financial discipline through consistent, on-time payments can offset potential concerns. For a deeper analysis of current lending criteria, explore insights provided by education loan lenders.

How Do You Choose the Right Student Loan Lender?

When evaluating lenders, focus on factors such as interest rates, repayment flexibility, and overall customer satisfaction, which directly affect the long‐term cost and management of your student loans. Compare detailed fee structures and repayment terms to ensure they align with your financial objectives. It is also advisable to review third‑party ratings and direct feedback from borrowers before making a decision. For additional guidance on lender selection and to review competitive offers, consider checking the best student loans for college.

Should I Consult a Financial Advisor Before Deciding on My Student Loan Refund?

When determining whether to keep, return, or reinvest your student loan refund, obtaining professional guidance can clarify complex financial scenarios. A qualified financial advisor can assess your overall debt profile, compare refinancing options, and evaluate the potential benefits of redirecting funds toward additional educational investments. For example, if you are considering further education as a strategy to improve long‐term career outcomes, an advisor might suggest exploring cost-effective programs. This approach may direct you to opportunities at the cheapest online university, ensuring that any additional academic investment is made with a clear understanding of its financial implications.

Will Returning My Student Loan Refund Improve My Income-Driven Repayment Options?

Returning your student loan refund by reducing the overall balance can favorably adjust your debt-to-income ratio, a key factor in qualifying for income-driven repayment plans. Lowering the principal through refund return may lead to more manageable monthly payment calculations and stronger eligibility profiles for federal payment programs. Additionally, by minimizing accrued interest over time, borrowers can maintain a strategic approach to debt management without compromising future borrowing power. For those considering further academic investment to enhance career prospects, exploring options like the easiest online master's degree programs may also align with long-term financial planning.

Does a Student Loan Refund Affect Loan Forgiveness Eligibility?

Keeping a student loan refund increases your overall balance, which may affect your standing in forgiveness programs by reducing the likelihood of meeting required cancellation thresholds. Some forgiveness initiatives require a borrower’s balance to fall within specific limits, and retaining the refund may inadvertently disqualify you or extend your repayment period. Consider reviewing individual program guidelines and consulting a financial advisor to assess how maintaining an elevated principal might impact your long‐term eligibility. For further insight on alternative financing options, explore health professions student loans.

How to Return Your Refund?

Contact Your Loan Servicer: Inform them of your intention to return the refund. Each servicer has specific procedures for processing returns.
Obtain the Correct Forms: Fill out any required forms provided by your loan servicer.
Return the Refund Promptly: Return the refund within the specified timeframe to ensure it’s applied to your principal balance, not treated as a future payment.

How To Manage Your Finances with a Student Loan Refund?

Okay, so you’ve decided to keep the refund because it makes more sense in your situation. However, it’s not money to be wantonly spent. Here are tips on how to use the loan refund wisely.

Budgeting with a Refund

If you decide to keep the refund, create a budget to ensure the money lasts throughout the semester. Prioritize essential expenses such as rent, utilities, groceries, and educational supplies.

Building an Emergency Fund

Consider setting aside a portion of your refund in a savings account as an emergency fund. This can help cover unexpected expenses without resorting to credit cards or additional loans.

Avoiding Unnecessary Spending

It’s tempting to use the refund for non-essential purchases, but doing so can lead to financial stress later. Stick to your budget and avoid splurging on items that don’t contribute to your education or well-being.

federal loan share off total student loan debt

Can Your Student Loan Refund Be Invested in Future Academic Opportunities?

Student loan refunds may also be strategically redirected to bolster further academic advancement. Some borrowers assess the potential return on investing in additional education by comparing program costs against anticipated career benefits. In such cases, using refunded funds to enroll in targeted graduate education—whether through accelerated master's pathways or specialized doctoral studies—can serve as a catalyst for enhanced professional growth. Consulting academic advisors is advisable to determine if this investment aligns with long-term career objectives and financial capacity. For instance, exploring options such as PhD programs online can offer an expedited route to advanced expertise in various fields.

How Can Student Loan Refunds Help Fund Nursing School?

For nursing students, managing education costs often extends beyond tuition and includes expenses such as clinical supplies, certification fees, and living costs during intensive clinical rotations. Here’s how student loan refunds can play a pivotal role and additional resources to explore:

Covering Essential Expenses Beyond Tuition

Nursing school comes with unique costs that can be covered by a student loan refund, such as:

Clinical supplies like scrubs, stethoscopes, and medical textbooks.
Licensing exam fees (e.g., NCLEX).
Transportation and housing during clinical rotations.

Student loan refunds offer flexibility in covering these costs, ensuring students can focus on their education without financial distractions.

Using Refunds Wisely for Nursing School

While a refund can provide financial relief, it’s crucial to manage the funds responsibly:

Prioritize Essential Needs: Allocate the refund toward necessary expenses like tuition gaps, certification fees, and living costs.
Avoid Overborrowing: Only borrow what you truly need to minimize your debt burden after graduation.

Alternative Financial Aid for Nursing Students

Beyond student loan refunds, nursing students have access to other funding options. Many grants, scholarships, and specific loans cater to nursing students, reducing reliance on refunds. For detailed guidance, visit our article on money for nursing school.

Key Findings

Low-income (39%) and high-income (40%) students borrow similarly, but 32% of low-income and 21% of high-income students exceed tuition costs.
The 2022 White House announcement of up to $10,000 in debt cancellation made refunds appealing, prompting borrowers to request them to lower balances.
Keeping the refund provides immediate relief and an emergency fund but increases your loan balance, leading to higher debt and longer repayment periods.
Four years after graduation, 48% of Black and 17% of White borrowers owe more than they borrowed, with overborrowing affecting 40% of Black and 22% of White graduate students.
To return your refund, contact your loan servicer, complete the necessary forms, and return it promptly to apply it to your principal balance.

Other Things You Should Know about Student Loan Refunds

What repayment strategies can I take after graduation?

Standard Repayment Plan. This plan involves fixed monthly payments over ten years. It’s the fastest way to repay your loans and minimizes the total interest paid.
Income-Driven Repayment Plans. These plans adjust your monthly payments based on your income and family size. They can extend your repayment period, reducing monthly payments but increasing the total interest paid over time.
Refinancing Your Loans. Refinancing can lower your interest rate and monthly payments. However, it’s typically only available for private loans, and you’ll need a good credit score and stable income to qualify.

How do I manage my student loan debt?

Stay Informed. Keep track of your loan balance, interest rates, and repayment terms. Regularly check your loan servicer’s website and contact them if you have any questions.
Make Extra Payments. Whenever possible, make extra payments toward your loan principal. This reduces your balance faster and lowers the overall interest you’ll pay.
Seek Financial Advice. If you’re struggling to manage your loans, consider speaking with a financial advisor. They can help you create a repayment plan and explore options like deferment or forbearance if you’re facing financial hardship.

Are refunded student loan payments taxable?

No, refunded student loan payments are not taxable. When you receive a refund for student loan payments made during the payment pause, it is not considered taxable income. However, this refund increases your overall loan balance, which accrues interest and must be repaid.

References: