2027 Accredited Online Educational Studies Bachelor's Degree Programs: How to Verify Quality
Co-Founder and Chief Data Scientist
Choosing an accredited online educational studies bachelor's degree program can feel overwhelming-many prospective students encounter programs claiming legitimacy without proper accreditation. This confusion risks investing time and money in degrees that employers or graduate schools may not recognize. According to the U.S. Department of Education, nearly 25% of online programs lack recognized accreditation, creating challenges in verifying educational quality.
This uncertainty impacts career advancement and licensure opportunities. This article examines key steps to verify program quality-covering accreditation types, recognized agencies, and red flags-to help readers confidently select reputable accredited online educational studies bachelor's degree programs.
Key Benefits of Knowing How to Verify the Quality of Accredited Online Educational Studies Bachelor's Degree Programs
- Knowing how to identify accredited programs helps students avoid diploma mills-an industry affecting nearly 10% of online degree seekers-ensuring genuine institutional legitimacy.
- Verification prevents enrollment in programs with unrecognized credentials, which can limit credit transfer and reduce employer or licensure acceptance.
- Quality checks protect against poor-value or fraudulent programs, allowing students to invest confidently in regionally accredited educational studies degrees with meaningful career prospects.
What Accreditation Bodies Are Authorized to Certify Online Educational Studies Bachelor's Degree Programs in the United States?
Accreditation confirms that online educational studies bachelor's degree programs meet established academic standards and deliver a valuable credential. There are two main types: institutional accreditation assesses the overall quality of a college or university, while programmatic accreditation evaluates specific degrees like educational studies, ensuring alignment with professional standards and licensing requirements.
- Regional Accreditation: The U.S. Department of Education recognizes six primary regional bodies responsible for accrediting institutions that offer online educational studies degrees. These include the Higher Learning Commission (HLC), Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission on Colleges (SACSCOC), New England Commission of Higher Education (NECHE), WASC Senior College and University Commission (WSCUC), Middle States Commission on Higher Education (MSCHE), and Northwest Commission on Colleges and Universities (NWCCU). Each operates regionally but holds equal authority over online programs across the nation.
- Institutional Oversight: Regional accreditation involves comprehensive evaluation of faculty qualifications, curriculum standards, student support services, and financial health. Institutions accredited by these bodies provide degrees that meet national benchmarks, promote credit transferability, and enhance employer recognition.
- Programmatic Accreditation: Some educational studies programs pursue accreditation from specialized agencies such as the Council for Accreditation of Educator Preparation (CAEP). This specialized review underscores the program's commitment to preparing professionals for careers in education and counseling, which can be crucial for employment and licensure.
- Verification Resource: Prospective students should verify both institutional and programmatic accreditation through the U.S. Department of Education's Database of Accredited Postsecondary Institutions and Programs (DAPIP). This database serves as an authoritative resource to confirm the legitimacy of online educational studies degrees and avoid diploma mills or unrecognized credentials.
Choosing an accredited program is essential to ensure academic quality and professional credibility. When exploring options, consider that accredited online educational studies bachelor's degree programs must meet rigorous standards set by recognized accreditation organizations to safeguard your investment in education.
Using tools like the DAPIP and researching national accreditation bodies authorized to certify educational studies bachelor's programs helps protect against poor-value programs.
For working adults or career changers looking to pursue affordable and reputable education, consulting sources like the College Scorecard and IPEDS alongside accreditation checks is highly recommended. If affordability is a priority, reviewing the cheapest MBA programs online can provide useful insights into cost-effective options in higher education pathways, complementing your search for quality in educational studies degrees.
How Can Prospective Students Verify Whether an Online Educational Studies Bachelor's Program Holds Valid, Current Accreditation?
Verify the accreditation status of an online educational studies bachelor's program by starting with trusted official sources. The U.S. Department of Education's Database of Accredited Postsecondary Institutions and Programs (DAPIP) and the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA) provide reliable lists of recognized accrediting bodies and their accredited colleges.
Checking these resources first helps confirm that a program is valid and meets quality standards.
- Cross-Reference Accreditation: After finding candidate programs, visit the accrediting agency's official website to ensure the institution is listed on their roster. Look for key details such as:
- Effective accreditation dates that demonstrate current, active status.
- The specific scope of accreditation that confirms the educational studies program or the institution is covered.
- Any probation, sanctions, or warnings that might reflect on program quality.
- Recognize Red Flags: Beware of schools claiming accreditation from agencies not recognized by the U.S. Department of Education or CHEA. These fake or unrecognized accrediting bodies often use misleading names, making degrees from such institutions unlikely to be accepted by employers or for licensure.
- Understand Accreditation Types: Regional accreditation usually ensures better credit transfer and wider acceptance. National accreditation and programmatic accreditation specific to Educational Studies also indicate certain quality measures important for career and educational advancement.
- Direct Contact: If accreditation status is unclear or contradictory, contact the accrediting body directly via phone or email. Confirming through official channels can resolve confusion and confirm the program's legitimacy.
- Transparency and Documentation: Legitimate online educational studies degrees typically provide clear accreditation information on the school's website, including links to the accreditor's site and relevant documentation in admissions materials.
Checking valid accreditation status of online educational studies degrees is vital to avoid diploma mills and ensure your degree holds real value. For those considering graduate study, you may find useful information about affordable options through MFT masters programs.
What Is the Difference Between Regional and National Accreditation for Online Educational Studies Bachelor's Programs, and Which Matters More?
Regional and national accreditation are both recognized forms of institutional oversight, but they differ in evaluation standards, transfer credit acceptance, and academic reputation. Understanding these distinctions can help students determine which type of accreditation aligns best with their educational goals and long-term career plans.
Credit Transferability: Credits earned from regionally accredited schools usually meet stricter academic standards, making them broadly accepted when students transfer or pursue graduate programs. Conversely, credits from nationally accredited institutions often face obstacles in transfer, limiting future educational paths.
Employer Recognition: Employers tend to regard degrees from regionally accredited colleges as more credible due to their rigorous quality reviews. National accreditation is less familiar in many fields, particularly education, which can affect job prospects for graduates.
Graduate School Eligibility: Competitive graduate programs and teacher certification tracks generally prefer or require degrees from regionally accredited schools. Degrees from nationally accredited institutions may not satisfy these standards, restricting advanced study opportunities.
Institution Types: National accreditation typically applies to career-focused, often for-profit schools centered on workforce readiness. Regionally accredited programs are most common at public or nonprofit universities emphasizing academic research and comprehensive curricula.
Terminology Shift: Although the U.S. Department of Education no longer officially distinguishes between regional and national accreditation, this historic divide still influences academic recognition, student experiences, and career outcomes in practice.
A professional who enrolled in an online educational studies bachelor's program shared how thoroughly verifying accreditation shaped his journey. "I wanted to be sure the degree would be recognized if I sought a master's or switched jobs," he explained. The process involved checking multiple official databases and contacting admissions to confirm their accrediting body.
"It felt overwhelming at first, but knowing my credits and degree would hold value offered real peace of mind." By prioritizing recognized accreditation before enrolling, he avoided programs with questionable standing, ensuring smoother credit transfer and greater employer confidence once he entered the education field.
Accreditation plays a critical role in ensuring an online bachelor’s degree meets established academic and professional quality standards. Students should understand which programmatic accreditation benchmarks apply to their field, as these standards can influence curriculum quality, licensure eligibility, and career opportunities after graduation.
Programmatic Accreditation Bodies: Specialized agencies like the Council for the Accreditation of Educator Preparation (CAEP) evaluate educational studies programs to ensure curricula, faculty qualifications, and student learning outcomes align with professional standards. Their recognition confirms a program's academic rigor and relevance.
Curriculum and Faculty Standards: Programs with programmatic accreditation must demonstrate that coursework is grounded in current research and teaching practices. Faculty members hold appropriate credentials and engage in ongoing professional development to maintain instructional quality within educational studies bachelor's programs.
Licensure and Certification Requirements: For many aspiring educators, completing a program with valid programmatic accreditation is essential to qualify for state licensure or certification. Such accreditation assures licensing boards that graduates have met content and practical experience benchmarks required for education careers.
Career Enhancement: Even when not mandatory, programmatic accreditation distinguishes graduates in the job market by validating the program's quality, often leading to better hiring opportunities and professional growth. Employers typically favor candidates from accredited programs over those without recognized credentials.
Employer and Licensing Board Preferences: In states with strict certification standards, licensing agencies may reject applicants who attended non-accredited programs. Employers in educational fields generally prefer graduates holding credentials from programs with established programmatic accreditation for assurance of candidate preparedness.
Professional Association Guidance: Students should consult relevant educational studies professional organizations to identify which programmatic accreditation best supports their career goals and regional job market requirements.
Prospective students comparing options, such as evaluating the criminal justice degree online cost, should also confirm that the program holds appropriate accreditation to ensure long-term academic and career value.
Accreditors ensure online educational studies bachelor's programs maintain high standards by assessing multiple aspects of curriculum quality.
- Learning Outcomes Assessment: Programs must establish clear, measurable objectives aligned with both academic and professional benchmarks. Regular evaluations confirm students achieve competence comparable to traditional settings.
- Faculty Qualification Reviews: Accredited programs require instructors to hold relevant academic credentials and demonstrate ongoing expertise. These qualifications undergo thorough verification to sustain teaching quality.
- Instructional Design Standards: Courses are carefully developed to engage students through interactive content, multimedia, and structured feedback that promote effective learning.
- Independent Curriculum Review: Prospective students can critically evaluate online programs by examining publicly available course catalogs, syllabi, and faculty profiles, offering transparency about academic expectations and instructor credentials.
- Third-Party Metrics: Objective data from sources like the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System, including student-to-faculty ratios and graduation rates, provide insight into program effectiveness and student outcomes.
- Direct Engagement: Requesting sample syllabi or connecting with current students helps gauge real academic rigor and personal experience beyond published information.
A professional who advanced her career after completing an online educational studies bachelor's program described the experience as "academically demanding but rewarding." She recalled how balancing coursework with work and family required strong time management.
Despite initial doubts about online rigor, she found the program's expectations "on par with in-person classes," especially through detailed assignments and regular interactions with faculty. Her advice for future students emphasized reaching out to current enrollees for honest perspectives and reviewing available course materials carefully to ensure a good fit.
Regional accreditors typically mandate that faculty in online educational studies bachelor's programs hold terminal degrees, such as PhDs or EdDs, to guarantee advanced subject expertise. This requirement ensures that those teaching core courses possess a high level of academic preparation and research proficiency essential for a rigorous curriculum.
Practical experience in education-like classroom teaching, administration, or curriculum design-also adds significant value, blending theoretical knowledge with real-world insight.
Evaluating a program's faculty often involves reviewing official bios on the institution's website, LinkedIn profiles, and any published research or professional portfolios. These resources provide transparency about faculty qualifications and current involvement in educational scholarship, helping prospective students discern the program's academic integrity.
The ratio of full-time to adjunct faculty influences the quality of student support. Programs staffed primarily by full-time faculty tend to offer more consistent mentorship and availability, which is crucial for students navigating online learning environments. Conversely, heavy reliance on adjunct instructors may indicate less opportunity for sustained faculty engagement and personalized guidance.
Applicants should proactively contact admissions or academic departments to inquire about how many courses are taught by full-time, terminally qualified faculty within the educational studies program. Such direct questions can reveal a program's commitment to maintaining a qualified and accessible teaching staff, complementing accreditation information and helping separate reputable offerings from diploma mills.
- Terminal Degree Requirements: Faculty usually need doctoral qualifications like PhDs or EdDs to ensure deep knowledge and rigorous instruction in educational studies.
- Relevant Experience: Practical educational backgrounds enhance faculty ability to link theory with hands-on expertise critical for quality teaching.
- Faculty Profiles: Institutional bios, LinkedIn, and publications offer clear evidence of faculty credentials and active scholarly participation.
- Full-Time vs Adjunct Ratio: Higher numbers of full-time faculty generally mean better mentorship and continuous student support in online programs.
- Direct Inquiries: Asking admissions about faculty teaching loads uncovers essential details about staff qualifications and program reliability.
Student learning outcomes (SLOs) specify the knowledge, skills, and abilities that graduates of accredited online educational studies bachelor's programs should demonstrate. Accreditation agencies require these programs to clearly define, assess, and publicly report SLOs to uphold academic quality and ensure accountability.
This process helps students, employers, and accrediting bodies confirm that programs meet rigorous standards and continuously enhance their offerings based on measurable results.
Common assessment tools in online educational studies include capstone projects that integrate theory and real-world application, standardized exams benchmarking student performance across institutions, internship evaluations that assess practical skills in workplace settings, and licensure pass rates where relevant. These varied methods collectively provide a comprehensive evaluation of graduate competencies.
Prospective students can evaluate a program's effectiveness by reviewing data published on institutional websites, accreditation self-study reports, and databases like the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS), which tracks graduation rates among other important metrics. These sources offer transparent insights into how well programs support student success and meet required standards.
Interpreting outcome data involves comparing program results to national benchmarks. High-performing programs typically show above-average graduation and licensure pass rates along with consistent improvement over time.
Conversely, programs with low or stagnant outcomes may indicate issues in instructional quality or student support that prospective students should carefully consider.
- Defined Outcomes: Accredited programs articulate clear graduate competencies to guide curriculum and assessments, ensuring students' abilities align with professional expectations.
- Multiple Assessment Tools: Programs employ capstones, exams, internships, and licensure rates to comprehensively measure student achievement across knowledge and practice.
- Public Reporting: Institutions and accrediting agencies publish outcome data openly, giving students essential information to compare program quality and progress.
- Reliable Data Sources: Metrics from IPEDS and accreditation self-studies provide trustworthy evidence about graduation success and professional preparedness.
- Benchmark Interpretation: Results above national averages signal strong program performance, while poor or static data highlight potential quality concerns needing attention.
The U.S. Department of Education plays a vital role in the accreditation process for online educational studies bachelor's programs by recognizing accrediting agencies that meet strict standards of academic quality. This federal recognition is crucial because it directly determines a program's eligibility to participate in Title IV federal financial aid programs.
Many students rely on this aid to finance their education, and without accreditation from a recognized agency, students enrolled in online educational studies programs risk losing access to government loans, grants, and work-study opportunities.
The National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI) advises the Department of Education on the recognition of accrediting bodies, conducting thorough evaluations of their policies and effectiveness in ensuring academic standards. Should an accreditor lose federal recognition, the schools and programs under its jurisdiction become ineligible for Title IV funds, which jeopardizes students' financial support and could reduce the value of their credentials.
Recent changes in distance education policies have raised expectations for online educational studies programs. The Department now requires enhanced oversight of course delivery, student engagement, and learning outcomes to protect students from subpar or deceptive programs.
These updates ensure that online degrees maintain academic rigor, foster credit transferability, and align with standards comparable to traditional campus programs.
While federal oversight helps prevent diploma mills and ensures a baseline quality, it does not guarantee the suitability or excellence of every program. Students should conduct detailed research into faculty qualifications, program reputation, and career support services before committing to a program.
For those seeking affordable options in related fields, consider exploring online masters in urban planning as another accessible pathway.
These aspects illustrate why understanding federal oversight and the U.S. Department of Education accreditation process for online educational studies bachelor's programs is critical for prospective students.
- Federal Recognition: The U.S. Department of Education recognizes accrediting agencies that certify legitimate educational quality, allowing accredited programs to participate in federal financial aid programs.
- NACIQI Role: This advisory committee reviews and advises on the recognition of accreditors, ensuring they uphold high standards essential for academic credibility and financial aid eligibility.
- Impact of Losing Recognition: When an accreditor loses federal recognition, the schools and programs under its oversight may become ineligible for Title IV funds, adversely affecting students' financial support and degree value.
- Distance Education Oversight: Updated policies require rigorous quality controls for online programs, including those in educational studies, addressing issues like academic rigor, student verification, and credit transferability.
- Baseline Quality Assurance: While federal oversight mitigates fraud risk, students must assess program specifics beyond accreditation, including faculty qualifications and career support, to identify quality education.
Students seeking affordable online educational studies bachelor's degree programs can leverage two key federal tools-the College Scorecard and the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS)-to assess academic quality and value. The College Scorecard lets users filter outcomes by field of study, enabling prospective students to view metrics specifically for educational studies graduates rather than institution-wide averages.
By entering the area of study, students can examine critical data such as completion rates, average student debt, median earnings after graduation, and loan repayment rates, all crucial indicators of a program's real-world effectiveness. This approach is essential when how to evaluate affordable online educational studies bachelor's programs using College Scorecard data is the focus.
The IPEDS Data Center offers complementary data highlighting institutional characteristics predictive of student success. Important metrics include retention rate and graduation rate within 150% of the normal program length, which provide insight into student persistence and degree completion. Additionally, outcomes for Pell Grant recipients reveal how well programs support financially disadvantaged students, a key consideration for those exploring affordable pathways.
These metrics are especially helpful when using IPEDS for reliable assessment of online educational studies degree quality.
Students should use both tools side by side to compare multiple programs on a level playing field, allowing informed decisions based on measurable outcomes rather than marketing claims. These free federal resources empower first-generation college students, working adults, and career changers to avoid diploma mills and low-value programs by focusing on accredited institutions with proven success.
- Field-Specific Filtering: The College Scorecard allows filtering by educational studies, providing targeted data on graduation rates and earnings for that field rather than generalized institution-wide results.
- Completion and Retention Rates: IPEDS data on graduation within 150% of normal time and student retention offer essential markers of program effectiveness and student persistence.
- Financial Outcomes: Examining average debt and loan repayment rates on the College Scorecard helps assess affordability and financial risk after graduation.
- Pell Grant Recipient Data: IPEDS highlights success rates for low-income students, revealing how well programs serve diverse economic backgrounds.
- Side-by-Side Comparison: Both tools enable students to compare multiple online educational studies programs to ensure informed enrollment decisions based on real data.
For more detailed options on affordable online interdisciplinary studies, consider exploring cheap online interdisciplinary studies degree options that align well with educational studies pathways and offer varied cost and quality profiles.
Diploma mills are entities offering degrees with little to no academic requirements, designed mainly to profit from unsuspecting students. These institutions often claim accreditation from bogus or unrecognized agencies to seem credible. In online educational studies bachelor's degree programs, diploma mills exploit the confusion around accreditation, using fake accreditors not acknowledged by trusted organizations like the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA) or the U.S. Department of Education's Database of Accredited Postsecondary Institutions and Programs (DAPIP).
Watch out for warning signs such as guaranteed degrees without coursework and accreditation from agencies that do not appear on CHEA or DAPIP lists. High-pressure enrollment tactics, including urgent deadlines and enticing offers, are also common methods to rush applicants before verifying legitimacy.
Always verify unfamiliar accrediting bodies through CHEA's database and the Department of Education's DAPIP before paying tuition. Degrees from nonaccredited or diploma mill schools are often rejected by employers, licensing authorities, and graduate programs, potentially hindering career progress.
A 2023 report from the National Center for Education Statistics found nearly 20% of students researching online degrees encountered questionable accreditation claims.
- Instant Degrees Without Coursework: Genuine programs demand significant study; quick degree promises usually mean poor academic standards.
- Unrecognized Accreditation: Confirm that accrediting agencies are listed on CHEA or DAPIP before enrolling.
- High-Pressure Recruitment: Urgency to enroll quickly often signals scams or untrustworthy schools.
- Employer and Licensing Rejections: Nonaccredited degrees frequently lack acceptance by professional and educational institutions.
- Verification Tools: Use CHEA and federal databases to verify school and accreditor authenticity before spending money.
Regionally accredited institutions are usually required to accept transfer credits only from other regionally accredited schools because they adhere to stringent academic standards recognized across higher education. In contrast, credits from nationally accredited or unaccredited educational studies programs are often rejected, as these institutions may not meet the rigorous quality benchmarks set by regional accreditors.
This disparity poses challenges for students beginning their journey at community colleges or less recognized schools with plans to transfer to four-year online educational studies programs. Without verifying accreditation compatibility, students risk losing credits, facing extra coursework, and incurring higher expenses.
To navigate these challenges, tools like the State Authorization Reciprocity Agreement (SARA) and articulation agreement databases are essential. These resources help students confirm official credit transfer pathways and ensure institutions have formal agreements for recognizing credits in educational studies programs.
Even completing a single semester at a non-accredited institution can create significant barriers to credit acceptance, delaying graduation and increasing the overall cost of education.
According to the National Center for Education Statistics, over 30% of undergraduates transfer at least once, highlighting the importance of understanding accreditation when planning academic progress.
- Regional Accreditation Ensures Credit Transfer: Credits from regionally accredited schools are widely accepted, supporting smooth transitions between institutions.
- National and Non-Accredited Credits Often Denied: These credits usually face rejection, which can lead to redundant courses and additional costs.
- SARA and Articulation Agreements Aid Transfer: These tools provide clear information on credit acceptance and formal transfer agreements.
- Impact of Non-Accredited Enrollment: Even brief study at non-accredited schools can block credit transfer and delay degree completion.
- High Transfer Rates Highlight Accreditation Importance: With many students transferring, understanding accreditation is critical for academic and financial planning.
What Graduates Say About How to Verify the Quality of Accredited Online Educational Studies Bachelor's Degree Programs
- Raphael: "I chose this online educational studies bachelor's degree program because its accreditation was clearly verified-giving me confidence in the quality and recognition of my diploma. The affordability stood out as well, making it possible for me to pursue my passion without excessive financial strain. Now that I've graduated, I've noticed that employers value my degree highly, which has opened doors to new career opportunities I hadn't imagined before."
- Russell: "Reflecting on my journey, selecting an accreditation-verified online educational studies bachelor's degree was essential to ensure my time and resources were well-invested. The program's cost was reasonable compared to traditional routes, especially considering the flexibility with weekly starts. Completing the degree has boosted my professional credentials and helped me transition smoothly into a leadership role within education administration."
- Theo: "As someone balancing work and study, I appreciated that each weekly start date allowed me to begin my accredited online educational studies bachelor's degree when it suited my schedule. I was impressed by the transparent accreditation and the reasonable tuition fees, which made the program feel like a smart investment. Graduating from this program truly enhanced my professional profile and gave me the confidence to advance in my career."
Other Things You Should Know About Educational Studies Degrees
Prospective students should ask about the program's accreditation status, faculty qualifications, graduation rates, student support services, and employment outcomes of graduates. Inquiring about any partnerships with educational institutions and the technology used for online learning can further ensure the program's reputation.
State licensing boards and employers typically verify accreditation by checking the degree-granting institution against recognized accrediting agencies listed by the U.S. Department of Education or the Council for Higher Education Accreditation. They specifically look for regional accreditation and confirm that the program meets state standards for educator preparation. Credentials from unaccredited institutions or those with only national accreditation may be rejected.
Quality accreditation directly affects eligibility for federal financial aid programs, including Pell Grants and student loans. Only students attending programs accredited by agencies recognized by the U.S. Department of Education can access these funds. Attending a non-accredited or improperly accredited program may limit financial aid options and increase out-of-pocket costs.
Accredited programs are typically re-evaluated every five to ten years to ensure they maintain academic standards and program quality. If a program fails to meet requirements or violates accreditation policies, accreditation can be placed on probation or revoked. Loss of accreditation can affect credit transfer, financial aid eligibility, and employer recognition of the degree.
- The Case for IES Postsecondary Studies: How IPEDS Provides Key Consumer Information About College Costs, Outcomes, and More https://www.ihep.org/the-case-for-ies-postsecondary-studies-how-ipeds-provides-key-consumer-information-about-college-costs-outcomes-and-more/
- How to Verify If an Online School Is Accredited - The World Financial Review https://worldfinancialreview.com/how-to-tell-if-an-online-school-is-accredited/
- The Importance of Accreditation for Online BBA Degree Programs https://www.dypatilonline.com/blogs/the-importance-of-accreditation-for-online-bba-degree-programs
- Accreditation In the United States https://usinfo.org/enus/education/overview/accreditation.html
- Why it Matters https://ps.sckans.edu/news/view/109/
- How Accreditation Impacts Student Success and Employability https://ukeducationbridge.co.uk/how-accreditation-impacts-student-success-and-employability/
- Welcome to DEAC | DEAC https://www.deac.org/
- How to Check if an Online Degree Is Real | Find Trusted Courses https://dsuonline.com/resources/blogs/how-to-check-if-an-online-degree-is-real/
- Future of Accreditation in E-Learning ‚ÄöѨ Prioritizing Public Interests https://elqn.org/the-future-of-accreditation-in-e-learning-prioritizing-public-interests/
- Information systems based model for the assessment of program learning outcomes in measuring the quality in higher education - Humanities and Social Sciences Communications https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-025-06259-9
